Asian American Women, Anxiety, and Self-Esteem

Image: Tree branches with green leaves and pink flowers, against blue sky in the background. Photo by Dr. Ellen J. Lin
  • Do you often feel nervous or unsettled?
  • Are you starting to get more headaches, upset stomach, or have jittery feelings, especially when you think about an upcoming event or something you regret?
  • Are you avoiding others or having a hard time connecting with others?
  • Feel as if you’re not good enough?

As women in this society, there are such specific standards: Be pleasant and smile, don’t speak up too much, stay thin and make sure you look well put-together. There is often a norm of shaming or blaming women–too fat, too loud, too bossy or bitchy, too flat-chested, too opinionated, dressing too sexy, looking too tired or too old, to speak in a “lady-like” voice and tone, to look fresh, cheerful, and young. Society has evolved to have impossible standards for women. See this brief video clip from the movie, Barbie, that captured these impossible, often opposing standards. At the same time, we’re expected to be the caretakers of those around us, attend to them, nurture them when they’re ill (whereas it’s so “nice” of men when they do the same).

Many of us grew up with mothers who both worked outside of the home and who got home and planned and cooked the balanced and healthy meals in addition to grocery shopping, made the doctors’ appointments for everyone in the household, tracked everyone’s schedule, made sure medications are taken on time including in the middle of the night, planned the outings, entertainments, and/or vacations, etc. Such expectations are even more prevalent in traditional patriarchal Asian households, although historically women are not expected to (or allowed to) work outside of the home.

Did you have female role models that showed that they took space for themselves, that spoke up and went against the cultural norm? Were they accepted? Were they “successful”? How were they treated?

What happens when you’re too tired? We’re suppose to still look cheerful and well put-together!

What did you learn growing up?

How did the people around you treat you or each other when you were young? Do you only remember receiving feedback about where you need to improve instead of celebrations for being who you are? Do you have memories of being teased, feeling like you don’t belong? Did you feel like you did not have people that you can turn to for support?

How did your parents communicate with each other and with others outside of the home? What happened when they got upset? What did you learn about expressions of love and care? Many Asian cultures value humility and harmony. This meant that it was not OK to talk about accomplishments, to stand out, or to complain. Added to experiences of racism or microaggressions in the U.S. society, many immigrants learned to swallow painful emotions, to put our head down and work even harder. Unfortunately, many who grew up in the more traditional Asian households did not having the awareness or encouragement to acknowledge or verbalize emotional struggles, not having any role models who practiced verbalizing compassion nor how proud we are of each other.

In addition to gender role expectations, Asian Americans also likely had to contend with the model minority expectations both at work and at home. Asians have been expected to be “smart” (as in highly educated), economically successful, good at math, etc. What happens when you do not fit such stereotypes?

So many of my clients think that “everyone else seems to be doing so well!” This is especially rampant with social media only showing cheerful, well-put-together, wildly economically successful folks. Many of us also learned to never talk about struggles outside of our immediate nuclear family.

The renowned therapist, John Gottman, found that stable, happy relationships maintain approximately five positive interactions for every one negative interaction during conflict. This is true for all relationships even though their research focused on couples.

This ratio is not a rigid daily quota but applies to interactions. (Ideally, you experienced this as a child with your significant caretakers.)

Positive interactions could include:

  • Compliments (not just on accomplishments but also on efforts).
  • Expressions of gratitude.
  • Being listened to attentively.
  • Expressing admiration, for example of character, of compassion, those internal goodness.

The idea is that positive interactions create emotional stability. This pattern helps relationships navigate disagreements without damaging their stability and connection.

My guess is that Gottman’s research may not have included many Asians in their sample, at least ones who were raised in more traditional Asian households. For the many Asian clients who have/had parents who were raised in an Asian country, especially East Asia, verbal expressions of warmth and care were usually not emphasized. Many Asian Americans have needed to learn to recognize that acts of service (e.g., cooking and serving food, making sure you dress warmly in cold weather) and not just verbal expressions, are also an expression of love and care. However, when the younger generation is more exposed to the U.S. culture of verbal expressions of love and care and start to judge their parents or elders through that lens, it is not unusual to feel a sense of longing, or worse, as if there is something wrong with us.

The challenge is that we cannot change the loved ones in our lives if they do not want to change. If we keep looking for these verbal acknowledgement, validation, or verbalized warmth from others, we may keep getting disappointed when others do not have such skills. Of the Asian American clients I have had over the years, many start to tear up when they start to experience verbalized appreciations from others in their life. Some even readily discount these expressions of appreciations or care, because they do not believe them, because they have not received much of them. When they start to practice these appreciations and care for themselves, their body starts to feel a sense of relaxation and release, especially when they start to believe in the genuine messages.

What are some ways that you’re taking care of yourself so that you can be more present and recognize, acknowledge your own inner being? Are you regularly making time to practice incorporating what uplifts you, what feeds you, recognizing the efforts you make over the years?  Do you have a community where you feel a sense of belonging and acceptance for who you are, including all of your quirks and imperfections? Do you find it hard to also accept your own imperfections, to take self-compassionate steps?

It helps to have a supportive social circle. I highly recommend that you build and stay connected with a support system, a group of loved ones who are caring and compassionate toward you, especially those who are understanding of the challenges of straddling between cultural norms as a minority, those who will allow you to be your authentic self. As adults, such a circle could take some time to build.

If you continue to have difficulties taking steps towards yourself or not feel grounded, finding it hard to feel relaxed much of the time, then please seek professional help with a licensed mental health professional. You deserve to be well, to be who you truly are, to take steps to focus on your own health! You deserve time to explore what contributed towards your struggles and barriers, what depletes ou, and to learn skills to replenish yourself, to reconnect with that powerful, centered being in you, so that you can actually feel more present and be more at ease when you’re with others.

Please feel free to call me at 408-828-8375 or send me an email to schedule a FREE 20-minute consult.